In pre-pandemic times, the specter of reduced productivity was a main reason bosses were wary of remote work. That line of reasoning has long been debunked, but some managers cling to it anyway, imposing in-person mandates despite workers’ resistance.
But Ethan Bernstein, an organizational behavior professor at Harvard Business School, doesn’t characterize the push-and-pull of the remote work wars as a power struggle. Rather, he sees it as a misunderstanding over what the best approach is.
“I don’t think people are fighting [over whether to return to the office] because they want to express their power; they are fighting for what they genuinely believe is the right thing to do,” Bernstein said in a recent interview with The Harvard Gazette.
But defining “right” is more fraught than it seems, and both sides—pro- and anti-office—base their preferences on their own experiences and beliefs.
“Doesn’t it seem silly that, in a moment of crisis during the pandemic, we all figured out how to keep working productively without all these conversations and debates, seemingly because we were just rolling up our sleeves collectively and getting work done?” he asked. “And now that we have the choice, it’s the choice that makes this hard.”
It’s a mystery why organizations are trying to go backward instead of forward, Bernstein tells Fortune. “What it comes down to is, just how much do we like changing the way we’ve learned to work all this time? People who are more senior, have more tenure, are less likely.”
Some companies are currently falling into what Bernstein defines as the “consensus trap”: Not knowing any other way forward, they decide to meet in the middle with two or three in-person days. This approach, Bernstein told The Gazette, doesn’t produce anything beyond “a suboptimal consensus.” It certainly doesn’t make a dent when it comes to productivity.
Bernstein says the misplaced focus on reaching an agreement is partly due to the word “hybrid” being long touted as a solution that could make everyone happy—or at least less miserable.
“Hybrid is the aspiration of being able to accommodate everything,” he explains to Fortune. Which is, of course, impossible. That’s despite the fact that ultimately, Bernstein says, most managers’ goals are focused on finding the right answer that works rather than a middle ground.
He refers to the 50-year-old organizational principle of “contingency theory,” which suggests that any kind of management structure must hinge on context.
“The famous response to ‘What should we do here?’ is ‘It depends,’” he says. “And with remote work, it does depend. We’re only doing this hybrid work battle in service of some strange notion of fairness.”
Bernstein is optimistic that companies will solve all the issues that the current workplace is grappling with within five to 10 years. Namely, articulating the kinds of problems any big decision is trying to solve.
He says he hasn’t seen any return-to-office announcements that clearly articulate why they’re making the decision in a way that seems evidence-based and compelling to all the different preferences, or that opens up the possibility of a first step toward a solution, even if we’re not sure what that solution is.
Rather than a company like Apple or Goldman Sachs releasing a hard-and-fast rule about a Labor Day return-to-office mandate, he hopes an issue-by-issue approach eventually trumps all. It’s a strategy that might involve a thought process such as, “‘We’re not collabing the way we used to. We tried x tools to solve that; they haven’t worked. Now we’re looking at y and z,’” he suggests. “That sounds better to me than 'Everyone back in for three days a week.’”
Over the next decade, Bernstein predicts, organizations that wouldn’t otherwise fail will end up failing, just because they’re stuck on the way they’re doing work—rather than the actual work they’re doing.
It remains to be seen whether insisting on Fridays in the office will have been worth that.
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com
Homes that sold for around $1 million in 2022 are almost 400 square feet smaller than those from the spring of 2020, according to Zillow.
Traditionally, the Japanese yen has been widely regarded as a safe haven asset by investors.
Investors need to pay close attention to Interface (TILE) stock based on the movements in the options market lately.
If you are looking for stocks that have gained strong momentum recently but are still trading at reasonable prices, China Automotive Systems (CAAS) could be a great choice. It is one of the several stocks that passed through our 'Fast-Paced Momentum at a Bargain' screen.
The Labor Department's August jobs report provided a key snapshot of the labor market's health amid growing fears that the U.S. is headed for a recession.
Contributions from the newly acquired Halfaker & Associates business and the ramp-up of new and existing contracts aid Science Applications' (SAIC) second-quarter fiscal 2023 performance.
Investors remain optimistic about Abiomed (ABMD) due to strength in its Impella product line.
Shell Plc (NYSE: SHEL) is looking for a new CEO, as Chief Executive Ben van Beurden is preparing to step down next year after nearly a decade, two company sources told Reuters. The board has shortlisted four candidates. During his tenure, van Beurden oversaw Shell's most significant acquisition in decades and steered the company through two major downturns and a pivotal move to slash greenhouse emissions. Related: Exxon, Shell Seek To Offload California Oil & Gas Joint Venture: Report. The sourc
Investors need to pay close attention to Golar LNG (GLNG) stock based on the movements in the options market lately.
Value investing is essentially about selecting stocks that are usually cheap but fundamentally sound. Unum (UNM), ArcBest (ARCB), Vishay Intertechnology (VSH) and Patrick Industries (PATK) boast low P/CF ratios.
The Beverages - Alcohol industry looks poised to gain from strong on-premise and off-premise demand, recovery in Travel Retail, innovation, and premiumization despite supply-chain disruptions. Players like DEO, BUD, STZ and BF.B will likely capitalize on the trends.
Investors need to pay close attention to Marathon Petroleum (MPC) stock based on the movements in the options market lately.
Why investing for the long run, especially if you buy certain popular stocks, could reap huge rewards.
Investors need to pay close attention to Tabula Rasa HealthCare (TRHC) stock based on the movements in the options market lately.
Federal labor regulator National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) looks to quash Amazon.com, Inc's (NASDAQ: AMZN) objections to a labor union's historic victory at one of its New York warehouses, the Washington Post reports. Amazon strongly disagreed with the conclusion and looked to appeal. Amazon believed the NLRB and the Amazon Labor Union (ALU) improperly influenced the election outcome and did not represent most of its team. In April, the ALU became the first to win an election at Amazon. Howev
Credit Suisse Group AG (NYSE: CS) is planning to cut around 5,000 jobs as part of a cost reduction drive, Reuters reported citing a source with direct knowledge of the matter. The source said that the discussion about job cuts is ongoing. Swiss newspaper Blick earlier reported layoffs of over 3,000. Credit Suisse is under increasing pressure to turn around the business and improve its financial resilience. The Swiss bank has dubbed 2022 a "transition" year. Related: Credit Suisse's Largest Owner
Facebook parent Meta Platforms Inc (NASDAQ: META) agreed to use Qualcomm Inc (NASDAQ: QCOM) produced custom chipsets for its Quest virtual reality devices at Berlin's consumer electronics conference, Reuters reports. Their engineering and product teams will collaborate to produce the chips powered by Qualcomm's Snapdragon platforms. The chips will be optimized specifically for the Quest's system specifications. Also Read: Read Why Qualcomm Failed To Mark AI Chip Debut With Meta Meta will continu
Flutterwave received one of Nigeria’s most coveted payments licenses from its central bank, signaling its status as a valuable player in the financial services sector despite recent challenges with regulators in other countries.
Volkswagen AG (OTC: VWAGY) owned sports car maker Porsche AG is planning to name Sajjad Khan to its executive board. Volkswagen noted Khan would focus primarily on Car-IT and become the eighth member of the body. Khan, a native of Pakistan with German citizenship, could additionally support the Volkswagen Group in an advisory role. Khan worked for Mercedes Benz Group AG (OTC: DMLRY) for more than six years until August 2021. As Chief Technology Officer, he was responsible for development in Conn
Laxman Narasimhan found himself during the pandemic in a small London apartment with his 80-year-old mother, separated from his wife and family. Now he’s Howard Schultz’s handpicked successor at Starbucks.